
Downsampling
I have received an unexpectedly large amount of traffic based around the iPad retina wallpaper post. Unexpected because in the past I have not experienced such a huge rush when posting like minded articles such as those for the original iPad and iPhone 4. It seems in this time demand for device specific wallpapers has exploded and I have seen countless content farming “retina wallpaper” websites and the like pop up all over the place. I am humbled that so many people have found their way over here and have been enjoying what I have made available.
With this boost comes a few problems though, the wider the scope of readers the more likely it will be that little issues will come up. I shouldn’t say problems, they aren’t problems, lets call it helpful or constructive feedback. Being the open minded person I am I figured I could answer a few questions and concerns and wanted to do it here rather than trying to cram them into Twitter.
Most questions that have come in over the last day or two have had to do with the retina images themselves. One was addressing the slightly off center nature of one of the photos, one was asking about JPG compression, and a few were about problems with the resolution.
The most alarming of these was a problem with the resolution of the images. I have heard varying reports that the images I made available were not at the new iPads full resolution but were actually downloading at 1024×1024. This is a strange issue and is both true and completely untrue at the same time. Oddly enough, Safari puts a limit on the maximum resolution of images it allows to be displayed in an apparent effort to increase the overall speed of web browsing. This limit falls in right at 1024, the resolution of the old iPad screen.
I can’t help but imagine that this is something that will be addressed in the future with a simple update and was somehow overlooked as they moved into the higher resolution screens. This and with ultra high resolution screens such as this, the web suddenly just got a lot more expensive. At any rate, it has been a confusing experience for myself and readers as when you click to download a high resolution wallpaper thats exactly what you expect to see. The trick here is that as soon as you tap and hold to save the image internally it will save at its full, original resolution. This is based on user reports because I do not have a new iPad on hand for testing so if anyone has any further questions, comments, or concerns on the matter please, let me know in the comments below or through email. More information on this issue or at least other places I have read about the problem are here, here, and also via podcast here on 5by5.
Now, for the other questions. There was an image, Going Home, that I missed the cropping a bit and was off center. I have re-cropped the image and simple replaced the file so if anyone else noticed this, please, delete the old version and update to the newer image.
The last thing that came up was someone who was adjusting an image a bit in photoshop and/or iPhoto and said the result was increased compression artifacts showing in the image. This is not some kind of sneaky way of keeping people from messing with my images (though thats a clever idea!) it is simply a symptom of me using the desktop versions of images as my source material rather than the originals. I do regret not having them with me here while I am traveling. I will be away from home until April 23rd and until then I am most likely unable to access those files. While I always save my wallpapers at the highest possible jpg compression rates there is still room for them to loose a bit of information in the process so while they look OK for their intended purpose, further editing may result with increased attention to the limitations of the JPG format.
Thats all for now, just a quick update to answer a few frequently asked questions on the new images. See you guys again soon!
Update: Further speculation (read here, and here) has lead me to believe that mobile safari may have an issue with JPG’s that are not progressive scan versions. I will go back through and save them again with this method and see if it clears up the bug. So frustrating. I am really hoping that this will not result in more artifacts in the images. I can’t spare another afternoon cropping images for quite some time. This would also indicate that even when saving images to the library they very well may also be the small size from what I am hearing…
Straight from apples Safari developer recourses there appears to be limits due to the amount or RAM in the devices. “The maximum decoded image size for JPEG is 32 megapixels using subsampling. JPEG images can be up to 32 megapixels due to subsampling, which allows JPEG images to decode to a size that has one sixteenth the number of pixels. JPEG images larger than 2 megapixels are subsampled—that is, decoded to a reduced size. JPEG subsampling allows the user to view images from the latest digital cameras.” Interesting indeed.
If anyone is having this issue, could you let me know in the comments if you are using Wi-Fi or if you are on a 3g/4g network. Just part of my troubleshooting.
Update two: To recap whats been going on, the issue has proved maddening and I have heard different reports from different readers about success or failure in downloading certain images versus others yet all were saves in exactly the same manner. Not to mention some reporting success in using the save to disk trick while others have no luck at all. Even more discussion on the issue of image size limitations on iOS here and according to this discussion it may be a bug within ios5, well, a “feature” that backfired and caused these issues.. It is still a bit maddening to deal with and most workarounds have failed so far for me so I am taking a break from it until someone can possible offer more information on what may be a god solution. At the moment I have read from readers that they have been successful in using their mac to download the full images and then emailing them to their iPads in order to get the larger size to save to the device. Meanwhile, I will continue to poke around and read whatever information comes my way about the subject. If anything changes I will let everyone know and make alterations to the files accordingly. Thanks for your patience.
[…] Update: There have been reports of users not seeing the full resolution wallpapers when the links are clicked below. This is a strange shortcoming of the iOS Safari browser that is limiting the size of the image as it is displayed. Tapping the image and saving it to your iPad should result in it saving the full size retina resolution. See here for more information. […]
Thanks for posting this article. I found nothing wrong with your previous retina pack…so just wanted to give a big thank you for sharing and caring. :D
Tapping and saving the image does not save it in its full resolution; the images are still 1024×1024 for me. I solved this problem by e-mailing the pictures to myself from my laptop.
I hope Apple fixes this! I would have expecting the limit to be lifted for direct links to images though…
one report I read said you can get past the problem by saving the originals as progressive jpeg files ( http://duncandavidson.com/blog/2012/03/photography_on_retina )
another somewhere that I read said that Safari doesn’t downsample .png files…
Hey, I think I have discovered a very simple solution!
I have a new iPad, when I am locked in portrait all the files are 1024. When I lock in landscape they are 2048!
Surely it can’t be that simple. Anyway worked for me.
Thanks for the great images
Sorry, not that simple. Some work some don’t. Must be an annoying problem.
[…] enlace directamente a las imágenes sino a la galería donde están todas y conviene recordar que debido a un bug en iOS 5 que provoca que las imágenes JPEG mayores de un tamaño sufren una reducción que provoca […]
[…] enlace directamente a las imágenes sino a la galería donde están todas y conviene recordar que debido a un bug en iOS 5 que provoca que las imágenes JPEG mayores de un tamaño sufren una reducción que provoca […]
Please refer to attached file for reference.
Hi,
As far as I’ve experimented, progressive JPEG’s do solve the issue. There might be another scenario where this doesn’t work, but I tried picking up a jpeg that was 9000px wide (the version that was saved for web as “optimized”), re-exported that same jpeg as “progressive” and the difference was heaven and hell. Did the trick for me. Cheers!
We’re a flock a group of volunteers and opening a
new scheme in our community. Your website offered us
with helpful helpful information and paintings on . You have made
an impressive activity and our whole
neighborhood will likely be thankful to
you .
Undeniably believe that you said . Your favorite reason seemed to be at the internet
simple factor to be aware of . I tell you , i definitely annoyed
think issues just do not recognize about .
You controlled perfectly as defined on all managed to hit the
nail on the top no need side-effects , other folks
could take a signal. Will likely be again to get more.
Thanks
My web-site … site (Magda)